I've been wanting to write an update about Carter, but whenever such an update involves lots of discussion of medications I hesitate. Why? Because psychiatric medications for children is an extremely controversial issue and I have been attacked (verbally and online) and watched friends endure attacks. Most recently, Meg over at Raising Bipolar drew fire from a vocal group of anti-psychiatry activists and sometimes I feel like, if I write about meds, I'm leading with my chin.
On the other hand, why do I write about Carter? Why do I tell the stories of my family's struggle and pain? Lots of reasons, and one is because I want to put a face on the hysterical media coverage about parents "drugging" their kids, to show that we are normal families in extraordinary circumstances, just like families with children who have cancer or diabetes. I want people, as many people as possible, to know that responsible, concerned parents have kids who are mentally ill, and some of us choose medicine as one of the ways that we help our kids.
So, all that said, I'm going to try (really, really try) to stop justifying the decisions that Brian and I make with regards to medicines and therapies for Carter. I want to be a woman and mother who has the courage of her convictions, and so maybe, maybe, if I move forward into the world acting as if I am that woman, it will eventually be true.
So.
Two months ago, we knew that risperidone (Risperdal) was not as effective as we'd hoped it would be for moderating Carter's mood instability and rage so we switched to one of the newer atypical antipsychotics, quetiapine (Seroquel). It worked great, too: his moods were adequately stabilized, he wasn't as ravenously hungry as on the risperidone, and he even enjoyed a significant decrease in anxiety.
But.
Have you ever been around a hyperactive kid? I'm not talking about an active kid, but one with genuine hyperactivity, where he or she honestly can't stop moving climbing running talking spinning yelling. Think of that hyperactive kid, then put her or him in a room with a dozen other kids who are also very hyper (in your mind, for goodness' sake; we don't want to create a cosmic event by doing this in reality). Now melt them all into one child, add a dash of red chili powder, and wind him up tight. That's what quetiapine did to Carter. Since most people who take quetiapine find it extremely sedating, this was more than a little surprising.
Carter was experiencing a side effect called akathisia, an indescribably awful feeling of restlessness. It's typically accompanied by feelings of acute anxiety and dysphoria, but Carter didn't have that which probably explains why it took us as long as it did to identify it. During the weeks he was on quetiapine, Carter was shockingly destructive (not because of anger but because he could not slow his body down), required more sleep meds than usual, and you know how people say, "I can't take you anywhere!"? I actually couldn't take him anywhere. I was afraid to take him to see Grammy for fear he'd break her, and I couldn't take him to stores because there's no way I can afford to pay for all the things he might have broken.
In the meantime, Carter's teachers greeted me at the end of every day looking like the proverbial deer in the headlights. Carter's psychologist and behavioral management specialist were both stunned by his level of hyperactivity. It was breathtaking. Truly.
The next atypical antipsychotic in line after quetiapine is aripiprazole (Abilify), but that drug was out of consideration from the start. His significant akathisia from quetiapine, plus the fact that I had an akathasia reaction to Aripiprazole several years ago, meant that the likelihood of a similar reaction was high.
Does this sound like a complex, frustrating dance in which Carter, Carter's illness, the meds, the psychiatrist, and Brian and I are engaged? That's exactly how it feels.
We took Carter off the quetiapine and put him back on the risperidone. Since that drug in combination with oxcarbazepine (Trileptal), the mood stabilizer he's been taking for about a year, has not been adequate, we needed to change to one that's more robust. Enter lithium.
Sigh.
That's about where we are now. Carter has been off quetiapine for nine days and he's back to his typical level of hyperactivity, which right now seems downright sedate. He's started the lithium, but we won't start to wean from the oxcarbazepine until he reaches a therapeutic level of lithium in his blood. As much as we hate to have him on so many medications at one time, changing too many meds too fast creates a risk of him becoming suddenly unstable. We are constantly trying to minimize the risks of these high-powered medicines while also minimizing the risks of this high-powered illness.
Even though lithium is one of the oldest and most effective of psychiatric medications, it's not usually a first-line drug. It requires close monitoring (all psychiatric medications do, of course; lithium requires extra) because too little lithium is useless, and too much is very dangerous. People being treated with lithium require regular blood tests, something that doesn't especially impress Carter. He had his first lithium level drawn this morning and while he did great, it's not something he and I look forward to doing every few months for the foreseeable future. Of course, I'll do whatever I need to do to keep him safe (including getting him some EMLA cream to make the draws easier), but I don't have to like it! We also have to be careful to keep him well hydrated as dehydration increases lithium concentration and can cause lithium toxicity.
I made it through college chemistry by the skin of my teeth, which just goes to show that you can learn anything if you need the knowledge bad enough. Here's hoping this is the last med change Carter has to endure for awhile. He deserves a nice, long period of stability. I want nothing, absolutely nothing in the whole world as much as I want that.
May 11, 2010
May 10, 2010
This Just In: Another Repetitious Redundancy Revealed
Brian pointed this one out to me and I must reveal it: an official repetitious redundancy. In the Miranda Warning (the statement of rights that is read to every person who is arrested at the time of said arrest here in the US), it says, "Anything you say can be used against you in a court of law."
Thank goodness the Miranda Warning cleared that up. Can you imagine if the criminals were all running around and assuming that they'd be tried in a court of tennis?
Thank goodness the Miranda Warning cleared that up. Can you imagine if the criminals were all running around and assuming that they'd be tried in a court of tennis?
May 7, 2010
Some Important PSAs
Heads up: I'm going to tell three upsetting stories. I don't want to surprise anyone.
I'm not an alarmist. (Which is a silly thing to say; no one things they're an alarmist, right? We all believe ourselves to be realists.) However, there are so many hazards in daily life, and a great many simple habits we can cultivate to keep ourselves and our families safe. It's not alarmist to buckle one's seatbelt in the car. PSA #1 falls into that "simple habit" category.
I'm a kind and loving person. (Also a silly thing to say; I know some people say they don't like people, but it's a rare person who truly doesn't give a shit about anyone.) Sometimes, though, helping someone else can put the helper and his or her family in harm's way. That should never, ever mean that we choose not to help (I don't want to live in that kind of world.), only that we must choose ways to help that protect everyone. PSA #2 is about protecting oneself while helping another.
I'm a smart person. (Yeah, yeah, I know. Have you ever met anyone who doesn't believe that they're one of the world's smartest people in some way or another?) Our information saturated culture, though, makes it very difficult to find the information that we need. And sometimes the information that product manufacturers choose to share with us is incomplete. PSA #3 is about a piece of information that can save lives.
PSA #1
A dozen years ago, my friend's little girl had open-heart surgery to repair a congenital defect. In the week she spent in the pediatric ICU, I got to know the mother of Alan,* the 14 month old baby in the next bed. He had a tracheostomy in place and his doctor kept him heavily sedated due to a near-drowning incident. The body of water in which he nearly drowned? The family dog's water bowl.
It does seem like a nearly impossible feat, doesn't it? Who imagines that anyone, even a baby, could drown in a dog's water dish? Alan was playing, pretending to be the dog, and was on his hands and knees, lapping at the water with his tongue. The floor around the water bowl was wet and slick. His hands slipped, he went face down into the bowl, and couldn't get traction to get himself back out. If he'd been an older child or an adult in a similar predicament, he might have saved himself by turning over or upending the bowl with the side of his face, but toddlers don't have problem solving skills like that.
Go put your pet's water bowls someplace where your pets can get them and your little children can't. I'm sure that's a very rare thing that happened to Alan, but obviously it's possible.
I'm afraid I can't tell you the rest of the story; my friend's little girl was released from the hospital and we never found out what happened to Alan.
PSA #2
Marian and I were best friends in middle and high school, and Tracey was Marian's younger sister. I remember Tracey as sweet, cute, and very annoying...pretty much just like my own younger sister.
In 2003, Tracey was living in North Carolina with her husband and their two young children. When Tracey's friend Holly expressed to her that her husband hurt her and she wanted to leave him, Tracey offered her a place to stay in her own home.
They arrived at Tracey's house late one evening after their shift at the restaurant where they were both waitresses. They were out of the car by the time they saw Holly's husband, Michael, armed with a steel shovel that he'd taken from Tracey's garage. Tracey ran for the house but Michael hit her with the shovel before she got there. He hit her several more times before he forced his wife into his car and left and left with her. Tracey died under her own bedroom window, just feet from her sleeping husband and children. More of Tracey's story is here.
Domestic violence is such a dark and terrible thing. I am blessed beyond measure to have never in my life lived in a family that was plagued by physical violence. I want every person on planet earth to experience the safety that I live with, knowing that the people who love me, no matter how angry they may be, will not hurt me in that way.
If you know someone whose partner (or any other person of any relationship) hurts her (or him), find a way to help. Encourage, help, support, love, and when she is ready to leave, help her get to a shelter. No, she (and her children if she has them) will not be as comfortable as she would be at your house, but you will ALL be safe. You can help her in a thousand ways, but only if you're still alive.
PSA #3
Here's the relationship: Brian's brother's wife has a sister named Lola. Several years ago, Lola's little girl, Jenna, had the flu and she was miserable with a high fever. Lola gave her acetaminophen according to the instructions on the label and it kept the fever low enough to at least take the edge off of Jenna's misery. Over the course of the flu, Jenna's doctor saw her twice. On Monday, he diagnosed flu and told Lola that she should use acetaminophen to control the fever. On Thursday, he told Lola that Jenna had not developed bronchitis or pneumonia as she had suspected and that she should continue giving her acetaminophen for the fever. That night, Jenna went to the hospital by ambulance after she suddenly became non-responsive. Within a few hours of arriving at the hospital, she was dead due to liver failure. The ME identified the cause of death as acetaminophen overdose.
And that, technically, WAS the cause of death, and that's how the media played the story. Unfortunately, not only did that wound the family (insult to injury, right?), but it gave a false impression that could put other children at risk. Lola gave her child the recommended dosage, never exceeded the maximum number of doses per day, and you know how the bottle says, "If symptoms persist longer than [x number of days] consult your physician"? Lola did that. Her physician advised her to continue giving Jenna the medicine.
Turns out, the max dose is only safe for a few days. (I am being deliberately vague here because I am not a physician, a pharmacist, or a medical professional of any kind, just a know-it-all blogger.) After those few days, the liver starts to struggle and in some cases, may fail entirely.
After Jenna died, Brian and I were scared about any and all over the counter (OTC) medications and I spoke to our pharmacist. Here are the suggestions he gave to me:**
There's more information on risks associated with acetaminophen use here.
Sad stories, I know, but the three families I wrote about want us all to learn what we can from their tragedies, so go forth and be careful. Use a condom, wear your seatbelt, find a great pharmacist, park in well lit areas, and remember to strike that all-important balance: always be cautious, never be fearful.
*I'm making up all the names except the ones in PSA #2.
**Check with your own healthcare providers if and when you have questions.
I'm not an alarmist. (Which is a silly thing to say; no one things they're an alarmist, right? We all believe ourselves to be realists.) However, there are so many hazards in daily life, and a great many simple habits we can cultivate to keep ourselves and our families safe. It's not alarmist to buckle one's seatbelt in the car. PSA #1 falls into that "simple habit" category.
I'm a kind and loving person. (Also a silly thing to say; I know some people say they don't like people, but it's a rare person who truly doesn't give a shit about anyone.) Sometimes, though, helping someone else can put the helper and his or her family in harm's way. That should never, ever mean that we choose not to help (I don't want to live in that kind of world.), only that we must choose ways to help that protect everyone. PSA #2 is about protecting oneself while helping another.
I'm a smart person. (Yeah, yeah, I know. Have you ever met anyone who doesn't believe that they're one of the world's smartest people in some way or another?) Our information saturated culture, though, makes it very difficult to find the information that we need. And sometimes the information that product manufacturers choose to share with us is incomplete. PSA #3 is about a piece of information that can save lives.
PSA #1
A dozen years ago, my friend's little girl had open-heart surgery to repair a congenital defect. In the week she spent in the pediatric ICU, I got to know the mother of Alan,* the 14 month old baby in the next bed. He had a tracheostomy in place and his doctor kept him heavily sedated due to a near-drowning incident. The body of water in which he nearly drowned? The family dog's water bowl.
It does seem like a nearly impossible feat, doesn't it? Who imagines that anyone, even a baby, could drown in a dog's water dish? Alan was playing, pretending to be the dog, and was on his hands and knees, lapping at the water with his tongue. The floor around the water bowl was wet and slick. His hands slipped, he went face down into the bowl, and couldn't get traction to get himself back out. If he'd been an older child or an adult in a similar predicament, he might have saved himself by turning over or upending the bowl with the side of his face, but toddlers don't have problem solving skills like that.
Go put your pet's water bowls someplace where your pets can get them and your little children can't. I'm sure that's a very rare thing that happened to Alan, but obviously it's possible.
I'm afraid I can't tell you the rest of the story; my friend's little girl was released from the hospital and we never found out what happened to Alan.
PSA #2
Marian and I were best friends in middle and high school, and Tracey was Marian's younger sister. I remember Tracey as sweet, cute, and very annoying...pretty much just like my own younger sister.
In 2003, Tracey was living in North Carolina with her husband and their two young children. When Tracey's friend Holly expressed to her that her husband hurt her and she wanted to leave him, Tracey offered her a place to stay in her own home.
They arrived at Tracey's house late one evening after their shift at the restaurant where they were both waitresses. They were out of the car by the time they saw Holly's husband, Michael, armed with a steel shovel that he'd taken from Tracey's garage. Tracey ran for the house but Michael hit her with the shovel before she got there. He hit her several more times before he forced his wife into his car and left and left with her. Tracey died under her own bedroom window, just feet from her sleeping husband and children. More of Tracey's story is here.
Domestic violence is such a dark and terrible thing. I am blessed beyond measure to have never in my life lived in a family that was plagued by physical violence. I want every person on planet earth to experience the safety that I live with, knowing that the people who love me, no matter how angry they may be, will not hurt me in that way.
If you know someone whose partner (or any other person of any relationship) hurts her (or him), find a way to help. Encourage, help, support, love, and when she is ready to leave, help her get to a shelter. No, she (and her children if she has them) will not be as comfortable as she would be at your house, but you will ALL be safe. You can help her in a thousand ways, but only if you're still alive.
PSA #3
Here's the relationship: Brian's brother's wife has a sister named Lola. Several years ago, Lola's little girl, Jenna, had the flu and she was miserable with a high fever. Lola gave her acetaminophen according to the instructions on the label and it kept the fever low enough to at least take the edge off of Jenna's misery. Over the course of the flu, Jenna's doctor saw her twice. On Monday, he diagnosed flu and told Lola that she should use acetaminophen to control the fever. On Thursday, he told Lola that Jenna had not developed bronchitis or pneumonia as she had suspected and that she should continue giving her acetaminophen for the fever. That night, Jenna went to the hospital by ambulance after she suddenly became non-responsive. Within a few hours of arriving at the hospital, she was dead due to liver failure. The ME identified the cause of death as acetaminophen overdose.
And that, technically, WAS the cause of death, and that's how the media played the story. Unfortunately, not only did that wound the family (insult to injury, right?), but it gave a false impression that could put other children at risk. Lola gave her child the recommended dosage, never exceeded the maximum number of doses per day, and you know how the bottle says, "If symptoms persist longer than [x number of days] consult your physician"? Lola did that. Her physician advised her to continue giving Jenna the medicine.
Turns out, the max dose is only safe for a few days. (I am being deliberately vague here because I am not a physician, a pharmacist, or a medical professional of any kind, just a know-it-all blogger.) After those few days, the liver starts to struggle and in some cases, may fail entirely.
After Jenna died, Brian and I were scared about any and all over the counter (OTC) medications and I spoke to our pharmacist. Here are the suggestions he gave to me:**
- Strike a balance with OTC pain relievers. Don't let your kids suffer with pain or fever, but don't medicate at the first sign of discomfort, either.
- When you have questions or concerns about medications, address those questions not only to your doctor, but to your pharmacist. Pharmacists are a hugely underutilized resource and we put ourselves and our children at risk when we do not avail ourselves of their expertise. Pharmacists specialize only in medicines. They know virtually everything and what they don't know, they know how to find out. Choose your pharmacist the same way you choose your other health care providers: carefully. Most of us don't choose our doctors based solely on how close they are to home; we shouldn't choose our pharmacists that way, either.
- When you need to use OTC pain relievers for several days, alternate the active ingredients. Give acetaminophen, then four hours later give ibuprofen, etc. You'll give much less than the maximum daily dose of either medicine and thereby reduce the risk of liver toxicity due to either one.
There's more information on risks associated with acetaminophen use here.
Sad stories, I know, but the three families I wrote about want us all to learn what we can from their tragedies, so go forth and be careful. Use a condom, wear your seatbelt, find a great pharmacist, park in well lit areas, and remember to strike that all-important balance: always be cautious, never be fearful.
*I'm making up all the names except the ones in PSA #2.
**Check with your own healthcare providers if and when you have questions.
May 6, 2010
There's love that gives kisses, and there's love that does dishes.

There's the love you feel when you watch your baby sleep and he's soft and limp, miraculous and sweet-smelling of milk.
Then there's the love that makes it possible to walk that same baby through the house through the fourth straight hour of fussing and crying. That's love with teeth.
Love is when you stay married to your partner in spite of all his annoying habits.
Love with teeth is when you never let those annoying habits grow large in your mind and heart.
Love is when you make the decision to breastfeed your new baby because you want to give him the best possible start.
Love with teeth is when you discover that breastfeeding your baby feels like you've got a staple gun having its way with your nipples and you keep nursing that baby anyway.
Love is when you tell a breastfeeding friend who is in pain that it will get easier, that she's doing great, that it will all be OK.
Love with teeth is when you hold her hand at 4 am and tell her that it will get easier, that she's doing great, that it will all be OK.
Lots of siblings adore each other when they are small.
Extraordinary siblings are still best friends when they're teenagers.
Love is when you get a new stepmom and you accept her from the start.
Love with teeth is when your stepmom is utterly lousy at fulfilling the role and you keep forgiving her and letting her try again. And again. And again.
Love is when you work your ass off trying to hold a troubled marriage together because a divorce will change your kids' lives forever.
Love with teeth is when you stay in that marriage for one last year after it dies because your daughter is a rabid mama's girl and she needs that time living with both parents to bond with her dad.
Love with fangs is when, a dozen years later, your daughter wants to go live with her dad and even though it breaks your heart, you let her go because that is what she says she needs to be happy.
Love is when you're willing to be a friend's birth assistant because her partner's culture forbids his participation.
Love with teeth is when you're still willing to be her birth partner at the 44th, the 52nd, then the 65th hour of labor and she has turned mean.
Love is when you feel guilty about bullying that weird, shy girl when you were both in 6th grade.
Love with teeth is when you go find that girl and pour your heart into writing the best, most sincere apology letter possible.
There's the love you feel when you see some pretty flowers and, inspired by sweet memories, buy some for your grandma.
And then there the love that makes it possible for you to give your grandma a manual disimpaction because you aren't willing to see her suffer even though the task goes far beyond your personal grossness tolerance threshold.
Love is when, just a few weeks before her wedding, your granddaughter's fiancée breaks up with her and the rest of the family is complaining about the trouble caused by non-refundable plane tickets and gifts that need to be returned, and you send flowers and a card.
Love with teeth is when, on the day of the wedding, you (only you) remember to call your granddaughter and make sure she knows that she is deeply loved.
There's the love you feel for your children because of who they are and what they do.
And then there's the love you feel for your children because they are.
No love that is real is ever easy.
Love with teeth never forgets that.
Sometimes, love with teeth holds on with all its might and refuses to let go no matter how tired and tattered it gets.
Sometimes, love with teeth screams and wails and resists, but it releases.
If it's easy, it's not love with teeth.
Love is when you have a friend and you enjoy her company.
Love with teeth is when you see each other through marriages and divorces, births, deaths, economic crises, cross-country moves, and a thousand other changes across 20 years and you still look forward to her calls and visits.
Love is when you find a partner you want to live with forever.
Love with teeth is when you find a partner you can't imagine living without.
Love is when you work hard to hold your family together, to make sure your children have everything they need to grow up safe and strong and healthy.
Love with teeth is when you do all that in the heart of the dust bowl.
Loving yourself means eating well, getting a pedicure or a massage, making sure you get enough sleep.
Love with teeth means you never let anyone (including yourself), any time, ever, treat you like you're anything less than a divine creature, apple of the creator's own eye, son or daughter of God.
Because you are. I am.
May 3, 2010
Patterns and Chaos
All science is the study of patterns. Biology is the study of patterns among living organisms. Chemistry is the study of elemental patterns. Sociology is the study of patterns of human behavior among humans in groups; psychology is the study of patterns of human behavior in individuals.
Human beings are hard-wired for patterns. The first thing that a human infant recognizes is the human face, or any representation of a two eyes over one nose over one mouth pattern, no matter how minimally rendered. We seek patterns, rely on them, create them. Our traffic laws are based on patterns, our worship services, our meals, our education system. Language is built of letters and sounds in patterns, from a baby's first words to Green Eggs and Ham to booze-fueled late-night philosophy debates to Hamlet. Music, table manners, architecture, the route you take to work, the way I brush my teeth: all patterns.
Mental illness is, at bottom, a pattern disruptor. Healthy people have daily patterns of high energy, low energy, and sleep. A person who is ill with depression becomes unpredictable and may sleep very little or a great deal, and may experience no periods of high energy. Schizophrenia disrupts patterns of cognition; depression and bipolar disrupt patterns of mood and energy; personality disorders disrupt patterns of identity.
Behaviorism is based on predictable human reactions to stimuli, simple cause-and-effect relationships. Parenting a neurotypical child, while not easy, is usually pretty straight-foward until adolescence if parents and other caregivers are reasonably consistent. Humans will repeat behavior that has consequences that feel good; behavior that has results that feel bad will become extinct.
Lay aside for a moment the significant debate about behaviorism, because right or wrong it's the foundation of most parenting advice in modern America. It's the thinking behind the vast majority of the criticism that we parents of children with emotional and behavioral differences receive. From the nasty onlooker in the grocery who says, "If that was my kid I'd give his ass a good whipping and straighten him out!" to the sticker charts that books advise to Supernanny's naughty chair, it's all based on a fundamental assumption that we can predict human behavior and therefore, shape that behavior.
Carter spits on the stairs sometimes, which most people would call "naughty" or "disobedient." In general I would agree, and when Carter started with the spitting I delivered consequences. I made him clean up the mess and gave him time-outs. When that didn't work, I upped the ante and revoked his computer privileges, sent him to bed early, and yelled at him. I failed to recognize my own bias toward behaviorism, the same bias that makes me so angry when other people use it to criticize me.
Carter wasn't spitting because he wanted to make me mad or because he was testing limits or because he is somehow naturally rebellious. He was spitting on the stairs because his hallucination of little men on the stairs with bows and arrows, combined with a delusion of "super spit," compelled him. I was punishing him for protecting himself and his family from a threat that was, for him, entirely real.
Even after seven years of living with Carter, 6+ years after beginning the journey toward accepting his differences, 3 years after acknowledging that he was mentally ill, nearly a year after we put the name "bipolar" to that mental illness, I still can't quite get past my own biases. So as much as I may rant and rage at a world that can't or won't embrace a new way of thinking about mental illness and its treatment, I will always have to see myself as one among many subjects of my own anger.
We can't control everything. That seems obvious on its surface, but the way we live, our cultural attitudes and ideas, say that it's anything but. As I learn this lesson, this hateful, putrid lesson of my own powerlessness, over and over, Jack London's stories (especially To Build a Fire) pop into my mind often. Just as humans are at the mercy of nature, the lesson in so many of London's stories, so Carter is at the mercy of his illness. Not always, of course. He is a person, whole and beautiful under the scrim of disorder on top, and he makes decisions and takes actions that belong to him. But sometimes the illness is so loud and his defenses are so weak that it dictates all of his behavior.
Powerlessness is a bitch.
Human beings are hard-wired for patterns. The first thing that a human infant recognizes is the human face, or any representation of a two eyes over one nose over one mouth pattern, no matter how minimally rendered. We seek patterns, rely on them, create them. Our traffic laws are based on patterns, our worship services, our meals, our education system. Language is built of letters and sounds in patterns, from a baby's first words to Green Eggs and Ham to booze-fueled late-night philosophy debates to Hamlet. Music, table manners, architecture, the route you take to work, the way I brush my teeth: all patterns.
Mental illness is, at bottom, a pattern disruptor. Healthy people have daily patterns of high energy, low energy, and sleep. A person who is ill with depression becomes unpredictable and may sleep very little or a great deal, and may experience no periods of high energy. Schizophrenia disrupts patterns of cognition; depression and bipolar disrupt patterns of mood and energy; personality disorders disrupt patterns of identity.
Behaviorism is based on predictable human reactions to stimuli, simple cause-and-effect relationships. Parenting a neurotypical child, while not easy, is usually pretty straight-foward until adolescence if parents and other caregivers are reasonably consistent. Humans will repeat behavior that has consequences that feel good; behavior that has results that feel bad will become extinct.
Lay aside for a moment the significant debate about behaviorism, because right or wrong it's the foundation of most parenting advice in modern America. It's the thinking behind the vast majority of the criticism that we parents of children with emotional and behavioral differences receive. From the nasty onlooker in the grocery who says, "If that was my kid I'd give his ass a good whipping and straighten him out!" to the sticker charts that books advise to Supernanny's naughty chair, it's all based on a fundamental assumption that we can predict human behavior and therefore, shape that behavior.
Carter spits on the stairs sometimes, which most people would call "naughty" or "disobedient." In general I would agree, and when Carter started with the spitting I delivered consequences. I made him clean up the mess and gave him time-outs. When that didn't work, I upped the ante and revoked his computer privileges, sent him to bed early, and yelled at him. I failed to recognize my own bias toward behaviorism, the same bias that makes me so angry when other people use it to criticize me.
Carter wasn't spitting because he wanted to make me mad or because he was testing limits or because he is somehow naturally rebellious. He was spitting on the stairs because his hallucination of little men on the stairs with bows and arrows, combined with a delusion of "super spit," compelled him. I was punishing him for protecting himself and his family from a threat that was, for him, entirely real.
Even after seven years of living with Carter, 6+ years after beginning the journey toward accepting his differences, 3 years after acknowledging that he was mentally ill, nearly a year after we put the name "bipolar" to that mental illness, I still can't quite get past my own biases. So as much as I may rant and rage at a world that can't or won't embrace a new way of thinking about mental illness and its treatment, I will always have to see myself as one among many subjects of my own anger.
We can't control everything. That seems obvious on its surface, but the way we live, our cultural attitudes and ideas, say that it's anything but. As I learn this lesson, this hateful, putrid lesson of my own powerlessness, over and over, Jack London's stories (especially To Build a Fire) pop into my mind often. Just as humans are at the mercy of nature, the lesson in so many of London's stories, so Carter is at the mercy of his illness. Not always, of course. He is a person, whole and beautiful under the scrim of disorder on top, and he makes decisions and takes actions that belong to him. But sometimes the illness is so loud and his defenses are so weak that it dictates all of his behavior.
Powerlessness is a bitch.
April 29, 2010
This is not Adrienne.
Remember when you took Art History 101 and they threw this slide up on the wall? The professor (or more likely some bonehead grad student with a seriously over-inflated sense of self-importance) said, "The French words on this painting by René Magritte say 'This is not a pipe.' What did he mean by that?" And you were all, "Duh, you self-important grad student ass. He means you can't smoke a painting."
Or was that just me? I may have had some issues with some of the grad students that taught my college survey courses.
The same lesson had more meaning for me when I took my first course in creative nonfiction. (Not taught, incidentally, by a grad student, self-important or otherwise, but by a young professor who is as humble as she is brilliant.) The Adrienne you meet here in my writing is a representation of the live, flesh and blood human being. Not Adrienne the person, but Adrienne the character.
Does this mean I'm deceiving you? Absolutely not. Or at least not intentionally; human nature being what it is, I'm sure that I'm deceiving myself about a good many things and, therefore, deceiving you. But I put a great deal of effort into being genuine here, even at the expense of my pride, because I firmly believe in the healing power of Truth.
My point? Getting there, I promise.
I've been on the internet a long time. My dad gave me a computer and a 33k modem in 1995 and I've been talking to people via a succession of computers ever since. First UseNet, then email listservs, then message boards, and now the bazillion and twelve ways offered by Web 2.0. The people I've met online have offered me information and and advice through every major event of my life, from my divorce to remarriage, step-parenting to infertility, and health issues to parenting a high needs baby. The internet provided my first community of parents of children with special needs. Nothing can replace the love and support of people I can see and touch, but my ether people* have enhanced my life immeasurably.
In all these years of talking with people on the internet, often about sensitive and/or controversial things, I've seen battles. Fights, arguments, debates, wars, and more than a few total freak-outs by more than a few people. I've been fortunate never to be at the center of any of those (I'd like to think it's because I'm a very nice person with excellent diplomacy skills, but it's probably just luck.), but that doesn't mean they haven't affected me. To watch one's community fracture, even when the fracture is timely and appropriate, is not fun.
I wonder how much of this heartache could be avoided if we all remembered that we are characters here in this placeless, spaceless world of the internet. No matter how honest we may strive to be, we are still characters, built of ones and zeros, presented for public view.
When someone attacks me on the internet, I know that they are removed from me, that they are attacking the character Adrienne, not the person Adrienne. That gives me some measure of emotional safety, something I sorely need as a writer who divulges a great deal of personal information for public consumption. I hope that I am open to the thoughtful opinions (positive and negative) that come my way, but for the mean-spirited attacks, I breathe deep and think to myself, "That person doesn't know me." Because that angry, bitter person who feel the need to call me names? Also a character, a representation.
In all of life, alone or in company, online or face-to-face, be kind. There is a real person behind every internet character you meet. Even when you disagree or someone treats you badly, show the world what it means to walk around wearing your dignity on the outside.
While you're being kind, be strong. It never ceases to amaze me the number of people who think that being mean is just "expressing an opinion." Not so. There's a great deal of difference between, "I disagree with your decision and I think it will have bad consequences," and "You're an idiot, but you'll get what's coming to you when the shit hits the fan!"
OK? Go forth and be the best person you can, then come back and portray your online character as honestly as possible. Be kind. Be strong.
Next blog post: Surplus Transfer and the Birth of Capitalism**
*I started calling them (you) ether people because it seemed bizarre that all these people (people who I could actually talk to, unlike the people in books or on TV) could come to me through a computer that lived, back then, in a playpen in my kitchen. When we went to high speed cable internet and you came to me via ethernet cable, the term entrenched itself in the family vernacular.
**Totally kidding. I was thinking about college and self-important asses and the term paper I wrote with that title arrived at the front of my brain.
Or was that just me? I may have had some issues with some of the grad students that taught my college survey courses.
The same lesson had more meaning for me when I took my first course in creative nonfiction. (Not taught, incidentally, by a grad student, self-important or otherwise, but by a young professor who is as humble as she is brilliant.) The Adrienne you meet here in my writing is a representation of the live, flesh and blood human being. Not Adrienne the person, but Adrienne the character.
Does this mean I'm deceiving you? Absolutely not. Or at least not intentionally; human nature being what it is, I'm sure that I'm deceiving myself about a good many things and, therefore, deceiving you. But I put a great deal of effort into being genuine here, even at the expense of my pride, because I firmly believe in the healing power of Truth.
My point? Getting there, I promise.
I've been on the internet a long time. My dad gave me a computer and a 33k modem in 1995 and I've been talking to people via a succession of computers ever since. First UseNet, then email listservs, then message boards, and now the bazillion and twelve ways offered by Web 2.0. The people I've met online have offered me information and and advice through every major event of my life, from my divorce to remarriage, step-parenting to infertility, and health issues to parenting a high needs baby. The internet provided my first community of parents of children with special needs. Nothing can replace the love and support of people I can see and touch, but my ether people* have enhanced my life immeasurably.
In all these years of talking with people on the internet, often about sensitive and/or controversial things, I've seen battles. Fights, arguments, debates, wars, and more than a few total freak-outs by more than a few people. I've been fortunate never to be at the center of any of those (I'd like to think it's because I'm a very nice person with excellent diplomacy skills, but it's probably just luck.), but that doesn't mean they haven't affected me. To watch one's community fracture, even when the fracture is timely and appropriate, is not fun.
I wonder how much of this heartache could be avoided if we all remembered that we are characters here in this placeless, spaceless world of the internet. No matter how honest we may strive to be, we are still characters, built of ones and zeros, presented for public view.
When someone attacks me on the internet, I know that they are removed from me, that they are attacking the character Adrienne, not the person Adrienne. That gives me some measure of emotional safety, something I sorely need as a writer who divulges a great deal of personal information for public consumption. I hope that I am open to the thoughtful opinions (positive and negative) that come my way, but for the mean-spirited attacks, I breathe deep and think to myself, "That person doesn't know me." Because that angry, bitter person who feel the need to call me names? Also a character, a representation.
In all of life, alone or in company, online or face-to-face, be kind. There is a real person behind every internet character you meet. Even when you disagree or someone treats you badly, show the world what it means to walk around wearing your dignity on the outside.
While you're being kind, be strong. It never ceases to amaze me the number of people who think that being mean is just "expressing an opinion." Not so. There's a great deal of difference between, "I disagree with your decision and I think it will have bad consequences," and "You're an idiot, but you'll get what's coming to you when the shit hits the fan!"
OK? Go forth and be the best person you can, then come back and portray your online character as honestly as possible. Be kind. Be strong.
Next blog post: Surplus Transfer and the Birth of Capitalism**
*I started calling them (you) ether people because it seemed bizarre that all these people (people who I could actually talk to, unlike the people in books or on TV) could come to me through a computer that lived, back then, in a playpen in my kitchen. When we went to high speed cable internet and you came to me via ethernet cable, the term entrenched itself in the family vernacular.
**Totally kidding. I was thinking about college and self-important asses and the term paper I wrote with that title arrived at the front of my brain.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)






.jpg)


.jpg)









.jpg)





